STARTERS
CRAB CAKE
Lotsa’ crab meat, not lotsa’ filler. Just ask Southern Living Magazine how good they are 11.50
STUFFED SHRIMP
Local shrimp stuffed with our signature crab cake and wrapped in bacon with a lemon dill dipping sauce13.50
CHIPS & SALSA
House made salsa served with freshly fried tortilla chips8.50
FRIED CHEESE
Little chunks of Wisconsin white cheddar cheese fried until yummy. Served with warm marinara9.50
SUSHI NACHOS*
Crispy wonton stacked with pan seared ahi tuna, avocado, asian tomato salsa, wasabi aioli and teriyaki ginger glaze13.50
SOUP N SALADS
SHRIMP N CRAB BISQUE
Our award winning recipe is smooth and creamy with a hint of sherry
Cup7.50 Bowl8.50
Add a grilled cheese to soup4.50
SIDE SALAD
Romaine, tomatoes, onion and cheese6.50
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD
Fried or grilled chicken breast tossed in your favorite wing sauce on romaine with ‘maters, onions, almond slivers and parmesan cheese15.50
BIG SALAD
Crisp romaine, avocado, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, parmesan cheese, bacon and egg 10.50
Add fried or grilled chicken, shrimp or oysters 6.50
Extra Dressing $1.25 Extra cheese $1.75
FRESH FRIED CATCH
SHRIMP
Always locally caught20.50
FLOUNDER
Light and crispy19.50
OYSTERS
Golden Fried Selects25.50
COMBO OF 2
Any of the two above, or a yummy crab cake26.50
ROUND MAN PLATTER
All of the above, plus a crab cake36.50
SAMMICHES
PRIME RIB SANDWICH
In-house slow roasted prime rib sliced thin with swiss cheese and hot au jus—BEST SELLER!!13.50
PORK CHOP SANDWICH ( The Flapper )
Center cut pork chop, fried with lettuce and tomato—try it tossed in a wing sauce10.50
BIG UGLY SMASH BURGER*
A double decker of smash patties with American cheese, pickles, and onions13.50
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
Chicken breast, fried or grilled and tossed in your favorite wing sauce with lettuce and tomato12.75
SARAH JANE BLT
Grilled shrimp, lettuce, tomato, avocado, bacon and herb mayo on toasted sourdough14.50
FLOUNDER SANDWICH
Crispy flounder with lettuce & ‘mater on a kaiser bun13.50
CRAB CAKE SANDWICH
One of our dynamite crab cakes with lettuce, tomato and Cajun remoulade14.50
BEYOND VEGGIE BURGER
It’s shaped like a burger but it’s got veggies in it, then we put veggies on top11.50
All sandwiches served with raw fries
Substitute french fries $1.50
Add cheese $1.75
Add bacon $2.75
Add avocado $2.25
WINGS
WET SAUCE FLAVOR
Buffalo -Mild, Medium, Hot
El Diablo, Teriyaki, Honey Mustard, BBQ, Spicy Teriyaki, Garlic Butter
DRY RUBS
Calabash, Lemon Pepper, Cajun, Jamaican Jerk
10 Wings
One flavor please17.50
20 Wings
Two flavors29.50
Add Taters – french fries or raw fries to any wing order 3.00
Fried ‘til crispy and served with ranch or bleu cheese
KID’S MENU
MAGGIE’S FAVORITE BURGER
Kid sized cheeseburger8.50
PEYTON’S PEE WEE SHRIMP
Junior sized shrimp basket10.50
SHARKFINN’S GRILLED CHEESE
White bread and American cheese. Just like mom’s7.50
WEE WILLIE’S FLOUNDER
Flounder for the little guys and gals10.50
SQUIDLEY’S CHICKEN TOES
Chicken fingers only wittier10.50
SQUIRRLEY SHIRLEY TEMPLE
A Higgins favorite5.50
GREAT BLUE WHALEES
Thar she blows!!!5.50
PURPLE PIRANHA PUNCH
It packs quite the bite…5.50
If you are over the age of 12 and you order off the kid’s menu you will be REQUIRED to wear a bib and do the chicken dance while holding a popsicle in your mouth…must provide your own popsicle!!!
LOCAL LIBATIONS
E. B. ICE TEA…
It’s Barton’s Long Island Ice Tea but with a secret Whaley’s twist8.95
LADIES FAVORITE…
After years of bartending this one always made ‘em smile. Mango rum, pineapple juice and sprite8.95
GRAPE SODA…
It tastes just like it sounds …… DELICIOUS!! Pinnacle Grape Vodka, sprite and just a splash of cranberry8.95
ISLAND MOMOSA…
Coconut rum, pineapple juice, champagne and splash of grenadine8.95
WHALEYS LEMONADE…
Cruzan strawberry rum, Pinnacle citrus vodka, sour mix, lemon-lime soda and blue curacao11.95
CRUZAN CONFUSION…
Cruzan coconut rum, Cruzan mango rum and pineapple juice11.95
BEERS
DRAFT BEER
Miller Light
Whaley Pale-y Ale-y
CRAFTS
Rotating
Seasonal Drafts
Bottles & Cans
DOMESTIC BEER
Bud
Bud Light
Miller Light
Michelob Ultra
Coors Light
Natural Light
PBR
Yuengling
O’Douls N/A
IMPORT BEER
Huger Street IPA
Corona
Corona Light
Landshark
Bud Light Lime
Heineken
Sam Adams Seasonal
Fat Tire
Red Stripe
Angry Orchard
Guinness Pub Draft
WINE
Coastal Vines… Chardonnay – Pinot Grigio Cabernet – Merlot
By The Glass 7.00 Bottle 22.00
HARD SELTZER
White Claw… Grapefruit – Lime – Black Cherry – Plus rotating flavors 6.50
BEVERAGES
Pepsi -Diet Pepsi -Stary -Ginger Ale -Club Soda
Tonic Water -Mountain Dew -Dr. Pepper -Lemonade
Sweet Tea -Unsweat Tea2.95
Orange Juice -Cranberry Juice
Pineapple Juice -Grapefruit Juice2.95
Bottled Water 2.95 Energy Drink 2.50
SPIRITS
Vodka
Grey Goose
Absolut
Smirnoff
Ketel One
Titos
Fire Fly
Deep Eddy
Pinnacle Orange
Pinnacle Cherry
Pinnacle Citrus
Pinnacle Grape
Pinnacle Raspberry
Pinnacle Whipped
Tequila
Patron Silver
Cuervo Gold
Sauza Gold
Gin
Tanqueray
Bombay Sapphire
Fleishman’s
Rum
Cruzan White
Cruzan Banana
Cruzan Black Cherry
Cruzan Strawberry
Cruzan Mango
Cruzan Coconut
Captain Morgan’s
Goslings
Whiskey-Blend-Scotch
Jim Beam
Jim Beam Apple
Jim Beam Peach
Canadian Club
Crown Royal
Glenlivet
Jameson
Johnnie Walker Red
Makers Mark
Seagram’s VO
Seagram’s 7
Woodford Reserve
Dewar’s
Crawford’s Scotch
Liqueur-Cordials
DuBouchett Amaretto
DeKuyper Buttershots
Fireball
Grand Mariner(Grand Ma)
Jagermeister
Kamora Coffee Liqueur
DeKuyper Peach Schnapps
Rumple Minze
Southern Comfort
Carolines Irish Cream
Sour Apple Pucker
Bartons Long Island